Scenario Based Training Vs. The Hard Knot

Scenario Based Training Vs. The Hard Knot

When people say ‘scenario-based training,’ they’re actually using a code phrase for ‘all the crap that comes before the actual violence.’ The yelling, the approach, the grabby man-dance.

Of course, once the violence starts it’s all the same old, same old–injury, injury, injury. Pedestrian, predictable, and downright boring.

All the stuff that comes before, all the stuff that people are fascinated with, is, for our purposes, a waste of time. The lead-in to violence for any given scenario is typically antisocial in nature. The questions people have are ‘how do I deal with his behavior?’ and ‘when do I decide to injure him?’ You already have the skills to deal with the former–talk him down, capitulate, or get the hell out of there. As for when to tear into someone, that’s a personal call you have to make in general terms ahead of time; in specific terms it’s based on how you read the situation.

If you recognize a threat and you think you can’t live with it, then get busy shutting him off. If you think it’s something you can live with–merely antisocial in nature–then act accordingly. Use your social skills, or set a new 100m dash record, or tear into him as you will.

In other words, act according to your comfort level.

This threshold point will vary from person to person based on life experience. Some people can stomach all kinds of crazy antisocial behavior; others will brook no threat whatsoever. Either way, it’s a personal judgment call. This means your response to that stuff is up to you to figure out, for yourself, on your own time. We’ll hand you the tool–you have to decide when you’ll swing it.

Another reason people want all the up-front stuff is because they are not in a hurry to get to the wreckage. They’re afraid. They want to stay in the semi-social realm for as long as possible and want to hang onto the idea that they are the Good Guy. If we maintain an attacker/defender dichotomy, i.e., ‘he came after me, so therefore he’s the Bad Guy, which automatically dubs me the Hero,’ we keep things nice and social. And for us sane humans, social equals comfortable.

Remember, we have, as a species, a natural disinclination to violence; society wouldn’t function if it were otherwise. Violence turns our stomachs. People will go to great lengths to avoid that discomfort.

Do you really want to spend your precious training time working within your comfort zone in contrived, antisocial scenarios with only a small percentage given over to the actual work of violence?

Or do you want to work where actual change occurs, the point where all violent acts become the same–the point of injury?

Look at it this way: we could waste your time by having you role-play stage productions of Serpico such that for every 20 minutes of floor time you only get two where you’re actually booting people. Instead, we have you experiencing violence for the full 20 minutes. Yes, half of that time is spent reacting for your partner, but you are still working where the buzzsaw hits the bone, at the point of injury. If you know what you’re doing you can actually learn more about violence while reacting than when it’s your turn. Ask anyone who’s been used by an instructor for a demo. It’s a difference you can feel. (Sometimes unfortunately so…)

Free fighting is the only ‘scenario’ you want to train in. To maximize your skill you need to practice that skill. In this case the skill is injuring people; it stands to reason that you want to spend as much time as possible at the point of injury. That’s what free fighting is. It’s you, changing everything in your favor, taking control of the man, the situation, through injury. What came before is immaterial–it has no bearing on what you’re doing to him. Did he yell? Or pull a gun? Did he grab you and knock you down? His ruptured testicles don’t care. Neither should you.

Now, for all that, the single caveat: if your job is hallmarked by common occurrences that lead to violence (as in law enforcement or the military) then working those specific scenarios has merit. Car stops, room clearing or other regularly occurring profiles–these scenarios are useful exercises for those who can expect to encounter them–but they’re pointless for the rest of us.

Here’s what it comes down to: use free fighting to wrap and entwine the hard knot of skill within you, learn to use your mind as a weapon and your body as a tool for violence. Then you can walk the Earth free of ‘rehearsal anxiety,’ free in the knowledge that if your current problem–no matter how it developed or came upon you–can only be solved by shutting down a human being, you know where the off-switch is. And once you reach for that switch, all violent conflict becomes the same.

All Latest Posts

  1. WHATS MISSING IN ALL SELF PROTECTION TRAINING & WHY THE MEDIA LIKES IT THAT WAY
  2. SELF-DEFENSE AND FIGHT SCIENCE
  3. PREVENT VIOLENCE VS. DO VIOLENCE: PART I
  4. PREVENT VIOLENCE VS. DO VIOLENCE: PART II
  5. SELF DEFENSE TRAINING: KILLING WITH RULES
  6. SELF-DEFENSE: STOP FIGHTING AND DELIVER A BEATING
  7. SELF PROTECTION QUESTION: HOW CAN I JUSTIFY THE USE OF VIOLENCE?
  8. SELF-PROTECTION MENTALITY: I WAS PREOCCUPIED WITH WHAT I WAS GOING TO DO TO HIM
  9. FIRST STRIKE: HOW AND WHY YOU SHOULD LAND IT
  10. INTIMIDATION DURING SELF PROTECTION IS A SUCKER’S GAME
  11. ANTISOCIAL CONFRONTATION: AGGRESSIVE, BADASS OR DEADLY?
  12. DEBILITATING INJURY: HOW TO TAKE A PUNCH
  13. TARGET FOCUS TRAINING PRINCIPLES IN A NUTSHELL
  14. SELF PROTECTION LESSON: MOVE WITH THE INJURED MAN
  15. SELF-DEFENSE CLASSES: WHO HAS THE REAL KOOL-AID?
  16. THE “NUCLEAR OPTION” OF LIFE OR DEATH SELF-DEFENSE
  17. INJURY IS THE ONLY GOAL OF VIOLENCE
  18. WHEN IS IT TIME TO LEARN SELF-DEFENSE TECHNIQUE?
  19. La guía de autodefensa de un teleadicto y otras historias
  20. Ein Couch-Potato-Leitfaden zur Selbstverteidigung und andere Geschichten
  21. SELF DEFENSE FACT: FIGHTING IS HARD. HURTING PEOPLE IS EASY.
  22. THE OL’ ONE-TWO
  23. ANTI-SOCIAL AGGRESSION AND TRAGEDY ARE AVOIDABLE
  24. PERSONAL SELF-DEFENSE: THERE ARE NO “EASY” TARGETS
  25. SELF-DEFENSE LESSONS: YOU CAN’T WAVE AN INVISIBLE GUN
  26. ARE YOU AGGRESSIVE, BADASS, OR DEADLY?
  27. THE TARGET FOCUS TRAINING EXPERIENCE
  28. SELF-DEFENSE Q&A: WHERE DOES TFT FIT INTO LAW ENFORCEMENT?
  29. IS LETHAL FORCE SELF-DEFENSE USEFUL IN YOUR EVERYDAY LIFE?
  30. “But I Don’t Want to Kill Anyone!”
  31. “But What If He Flinches?”
  32. A Couch Potato’s Guide To Self Defense and Other Stories
  33. Why Not Just Buy a Gun?
  34. It’s a Nice Idea–But Does It Really Work?
  35. There’s only one way to train
  36. The Beating, the Breaking, or the Fall from a Great Height?
  37. Speed: The Last Thing You Need For Self-Defense
  38. Fighting Through Injury
  39. Targeting: Secret To Self Defense Success?
  40. Are You Learning To Fight… Or To Dance?
  41. Generación de máxima potencia
  42. Maximale Leistung erzeugen
  43. What Color Crayon Should I Use For A Ruptured Spleen?
  44. INJURY – The Only Goal Of Violence
  45. Violence as a Survival Tool
  46. Generating Maximum Power
  47. Social Confrontation vs Asocial Violence – Part 3
  48. Social Confrontation vs Asocial Violence – Part 2
  49. Social Confrontation vs Asocial Violence – Part 1
  50. Striking… TFT Style
  51. The Final Word in Context: MURDER
  52. Scenario Based Training Vs. The Hard Knot
  53. Time to Stop Lying to Yourself
  54. The Mindset to Survive and the Will to Win
  55. Training to “Wait and See”
  56. Access the Meat: Choosing the Level of Interaction in Violent Conflict
  57. Why Self-Defense is NOT Enough…
  58. SOCIAL OR ASOCIAL VIOLENCE – WHY BOTHER?
  59. THE ULTIMATE SELF-DEFENSE FIGHTING TECHNIQUE
  60. STRIKING – TFT STYLE
  61. ACCESS THE MEAT: CHOOSING THE LEVEL OF INTERACTION IN VIOLENT CONFLICT
  62. SELF DEFENSE IS NOT ENOUGH
  63. LEARN SELF DEFENSE: SHUT UP AND HURT HIM
  64. WINNING VIOLENCE: WOULD IT MATTER TO A SERIAL KILLER?
  65. DO SELF DEFENSE LESSONS LIKE TFT REALLY WORK?
  66. SELF-DEFENSE FACT: INJURY IS WHAT WORKS IN VIOLENCE
  67. SELF-DEFENSE TRUTH: WORRYING ABOUT LOSING WON’T MAKE YOU WIN
  68. LEARNING SELF-DEFENSE IS NOT ENOUGH
  69. PROTECT YOURSELF: BUILD A BETTER MONSTER
  70. LEARN SELF DEFENSE: THE DEFINITION OF VIOLENCE
  71. SELF DEFENSE QUESTION: ARE THERE ANY DOWNSIDES TO LIVING IN THE CAUSE STATE?
  72. A SELF DEFENSE TOOL IS JUST A TOOL
  73. SURVIVING THE AFTERMATH OF SELF-DEFENSE
  74. MULTIPLE ATTACKERS SELF-DEFENSE: PART THREE
  75. SELF PROTECTION: NATURE OR NURTURE?
  76. SELF DEFENSE AND YOUR EXPECTATIONS
  77. UNDERSTANDING VIOLENCE: FOUR LEVELS OF HUMAN INTERACTION
  78. WHY DO WE TEACH LETHAL SELF DEFENSE?
  79. SELF DEFENSE MINDSET: WHAT IS YOUR LIFE WORTH?
  80. BUT I DON’T WANT TO KILL ANYONE!
  81. SELF DEFENSE TRAINING VS. MMA TRAINING
  82. MULTIPLE ATTACKERS SELF DEFENSE: PART TWO
  83. ES IST EINE MÄNNER WELT… ODER WARUM ICH ES HASSE, FRAUEN ZU TRAINIEREN
  84. IMPACTANTE ESTUDIO REVELA QUE LA CONDICIÓN FÍSICA NO ES UN FACTOR CUANDO LUCHA POR SU VIDA
  85. CUANDO TU VIDA ESTÁ EN JUEGO, AQUÍ ES CÓMO JUGAR SEGÚN LAS REGLAS
  86. SCHOCKIERENDE STUDIE ZEIGT, DASS FITNESS KEIN FAKTOR IST, WENN UM IHR LEBEN KÄMPFT
  87. WENN IHR LEBEN AUF DEM SPIEL STEHT, SO SPIELEN SIE NACH DEN REGELN
  88. MANIOBRAS CORPORAL PARA EMPRESARIOS
  89. KÖRPERMANÖVER FÜR GESCHÄFTSLEUTE
  90. ES UN MUNDO DE HOMBRES… O POR QUÉ ODIO ENTRENAR MUJERES
  91. USING VIOLENCE: DEAD MEN TELL NO TALES
  92. MULTIPLE ATTACKERS SELF DEFENSE: PART ONE
  93. SLOW YOUR SELF PROTECTION TRAINING DOWN
  94. SELF DEFENSE TECHNIQUE: BUILD YOUR TARGET MAP
  95. SELF DEFENSE MOVES: KNOW HOW TO BREAK A NECK
  96. VIOLENCE & KISS (OR KILL IT SIMPLY, STUPID)
  97. SELF DEFENSE IS A SHAM • PART 2
  98. PRACTICING SELF DEFENSE: CAN BIGGER-STRONGER-FASTER MAKE A DIFFERENCE?
  99. THE BLUEPRINT FOR SUCCESS IN USING VIOLENCE
  100. SELF DEFENSE IS A SHAM • PART 1
  101. VIOLENCE STARTS AND ENDS WITH YOU
  102. FORGET FIGHTING. DELIVER AN INJURY.
  103. A FIREARM ISN’T EVERYTHING
  104. NAILING DOWN INTENT
  105. THE ANATOMY OF A SELF DEFENSE SEMINAR
  106. THE SELF DEFENSE PARADOX: IF YOU WANT A TRULY PEACEFUL LIFE, THEN TRAIN VIOLENCE.
  107. WHEN YOUR LIFE IS ON THE LINE, HERE’S HOW YOU PLAY BY THE RULES
  108. SHOCKING STUDY REVEALS FITNESS NOT A FACTOR WHEN FIGHTING FOR YOUR LIFE
  109. BODY MANEUVERS FOR BUSINESSMEN
  110. ITS A MAN’S WORLD… OR WHY I HATE TRAINING WOMEN

Stay up to date and receive exclusive self-protection tips & resources.

Books by Tim Larkin

Scroll to Top

Search

Search for anything regarding on the site here:

Login To Your Account

Create Free Account